Beauty / Vol. VII Best Of Updated September 22, 2026

THE BESTSELFTANNERS

Mousse, drops, gradual — what doesn’t streak, smell, or ruin white sheets.

Sitting at the end of a wooden dock over turquoise water, reef line on the horizon
No laying out required
On the beach in a white swimsuit, hair wet
The bathroom shelf, where all of this happens
exfoliate the day before, not the day of →
Lauren tested
Words & testing · Lauren Fowler Open story ↓ Photograph · Lauren
Filed under
Beauty / Body / Best Of

Tested over
2 years

Published
September 22, 2026

Best by Lauren may earn a commission when you shop through certain links. Every product here was bought with my own money or tested for at least six weeks. No brand has paid to be included, and nothing is ranked higher because it pays more.

I am naturally very pale and I spend most of the year somewhere sunny, which is a combination that makes self tan the safer choice more or less permanently.

Two years of testing, mostly in the least glamorous way possible: one product on one leg, another on the other, photographed daily under the same bathroom light.

Prep is most of it

Exfoliate the day before, not the same day. Same-day scrubbing leaves skin slightly raw and the tan grabs unevenly, which is the single most common cause of a patchy result.

Moisturise the dry spots only — knees, ankles, elbows, knuckles — about twenty minutes before you apply. Those areas absorb more and go darker, and a barrier layer evens it out.

Shave the day before as well. Freshly shaved skin has open follicles and that is where the little dark dots come from.

Mousse, drops, or gradual

Mousse is the fastest and the most forgiving because the guide colour shows you what you have done. It is also the one most likely to transfer onto sheets, so give it the full development time before bed.

Drops mixed into your own moisturiser are the most controllable and the hardest to get badly wrong. Slowest to build, best for the face.

Gradual lotions are the ones I recommend to anyone nervous. You cannot really ruin anything and you can stop when it is dark enough.

The white-sheet test

This is the test that eliminated most of what I tried. A tanner that looks perfect and then leaves a shadow on a white hotel duvet is a tanner I cannot travel with.

The fix that works regardless of product: apply in the morning, rinse the guide colour off before bed, and sleep in something old anyway.

The smell

Every self tan smells eventually — that is the DHA reacting, not the fragrance. Products differ in how well they mask it for the first few hours and not at all in what happens overnight.

A shower the next morning removes most of it. Anything claiming to have solved it entirely has not.

The film6 frames · Two years of one leg at a time
A cap and towel on a lounger in full sun
The alternative
On the beach in a white swimsuit, hair wet
Sunglasses on the lawn
Taking a photograph from the edge of a hillside pool
The bathroom shelf, where all of this happens
Questions
How do you stop self tan from going patchy?

Exfoliate the day before rather than the same day, and moisturise knees, ankles and elbows twenty minutes before applying. Most patchiness is a prep problem, not a product problem.

Does self tanner ruin white sheets?

Mousse can. Apply in the morning, rinse the guide colour before bed, and the transfer mostly disappears.

What is the best self tanner for very pale skin?

Drops mixed into your own moisturiser — slowest to build and the hardest to get badly wrong.

Why does self tan smell?

The DHA reacting with skin, not the fragrance. Products differ in how long they mask it and not at all in what happens overnight.

Best by Lauren Awards 2027
xo Lauren
Keep readingMore from Best by Lauren
The Weekly Best

Seven bests.
Every Sunday.

No spam. Unsubscribe whenever.

Hammock strung between palms over a lagoon, Maldives

written from here,
most weeks

  1. The best thing I bought 01
  2. The best thing I used 02
  3. The best place I went 03
  4. The best thing I ate 04
  5. The best thing I read 05
  6. Five things worth knowing 06
  7. The best thing that happened 07